Forgot your password?

Five Cons of Oak Writing Desks

By Edited Jan 8, 2015 1 0

Are oak desks really the best way to go?

While taking nothing away from the many benefits that a solid work like oak brings to any furniture it's used with, it's important for any potentially buyer to be aware of five potential drawbacks that can come with choosing an oak writing desk over other models. There's no question that these are good pieces of furniture and it might turn out that a model made out of oak is indeed the absolute best choice for you. However, that's not a guarantee and you should study your other options before diving in with a large investment.

Even today, oak is expensive. This isn't necessarily bad in and of itself and there is a reason for it. Oak is a durable wood that is known for quality craftsmanship and for being able to last years or even decades. However those benefits are also fully reflected in it's hefty price tag. Budget shoppers might be better off looking for more modern material desks such as particle board or steel for a better value with equal durability. This isn't as sweet as a desk made from actual wood, but depending on what you actually need, and if you know you'll replace the desk in a few years anyway, 

If the hefty price tag isn't the issue, then consider the heft of the oak writing desk. While all solid wood desks are going to be heavier than cheaper alternatives like particleboard or synthetic material, even among wood oak is very dense and heavy wood. If the desk is actually made the old fashioned way with wood from top to bottom, then oak is going to be heavy, and extremely tiring to move at any given time. If you're going to have to do a lot of moving, you will want to really reconsider going with oak as your number one choice. This is especially true if you are going to be moving a lot. Even if you're big on solid wood, look at choices like walnut, cherry, or maple. These are all still lighter in weight than your current oak wood options.

Aesthetically speaking oak isn't necessarily the first choice for desks anymore. While oak was used traditionally, other woods such as pine, maple, walnut, cherry or mahogany have emerged on the market to offer more elegant options. Cherry offers more warmth and a softer finish to furniture than oak does. Mahogany is still the classic standard when it comes to sophistication, and walnut and maple both offer some exceptional options. Pine is seen as a cheaper soft wood option, but they are still solid and can be more easily stained and painted than some other options.

A good example of a modern writing desk

Sauder Orchard Hills Computer Desk with Hutch, Carolina Oak
Amazon Price: $249.99 $204.00 Buy Now
(price as of Jan 8, 2015)
This Carolina Oak writing desk by Sauder Orchard Hills is also commonly referred to as a computer desk, although with the movement in modern technology towards computers, these two types of desks are becoming more and more interchangeable in description.

Two more thoughts on writing desks made of oak

Oak might not be a good choice for a writing desk either if the rest of the furniture in the room has a modern or contemporary feel. This isn't to bash the overall appearance of oak furniture, much of which looks great, but it's also important to note that oak has a very pronounced grain and this can stand out in sharp contrast to other synthetic veneers and finishes, be it chairs, flooring or counter tops. Oak has a great look, but it's one that doesn't blend in with every particular style out there. If you do choose oak, make sure an oak writing desk will accentuate the other pieces in the room instead of presenting a mismatch. Everything looks good in a storeroom, but these very same items also need to look good in another environment.

Buyer beware also of fraudulent product whether intentional or unintentional. What makes something an "oak desk?" Is it a writing desk that is 100% oak or can you still say that with some cheaper desks that are mostly cheap materials but may have an oak finish which is simply an oak veneer, which is generally 1/8th of an inch thick. This is more prone to cracking, peeling, and producing an uneven writing surface. In whatever style of desk you choose be an informed shopper, and by all means go with oak if the advantages outweigh these five cons of oak writing desks.

While these types of furniture have their own place, as well, when you're looking at a true writing desk, you deserve to get the actual level of quality that you are in fact paying for. If not, then maybe it's time to look at some of the stylish and interesting alternatives that are out there.

Modern and beautiful L-style desk

Home Styles Modern Craftsman Corner L Desk and Mobile File
Amazon Price: $2,229.99 $1,397.00 Buy Now
(price as of Jan 8, 2015)
This modern corner L Desk is the perfect combination of classic wood and modern design for electronics use. This is an outstanding combination and makes for a great alternative to often heavier, bulkier, and less space friendly oak writing desks.

Beautiful Chinese redwood pearly inlay writing desk video

This video shows just how beautiful, decorative, and sophisticated your options can be when it comes to tracking down the best writing desk for your home or office. Don't settle for less than you truly want just because you think you have to. There are many options out there!

Simple but beautiful writing desk

Leick Laptop/Writing Desk, Chocolate Cherry Finish
Amazon Price: $249.00 $218.14 Buy Now
(price as of Jan 8, 2015)
This beautiful chocolate cherry finished wood writing desk is another example of how a writing desk can be relatively light, absolutely beautiful, and still serve its clear purpose. Why choose one over the other when you can have beauty and simple basic functionality?


Add a new comment - No HTML
You must be logged in and verified to post a comment. Please log in or sign up to comment.


Explore InfoBarrel

Auto Business & Money Entertainment Environment Health History Home & Garden InfoBarrel University Lifestyle Sports Technology Travel & Places
© Copyright 2008 - 2016 by Hinzie Media Inc. Terms of Service Privacy Policy XML Sitemap

Follow IB Lifestyle