Forgot your password?

How to Respond to People Who Tell You Christ was Not Born at Christmas

By Edited Feb 11, 2016 4 7

Adoration of the Infant by Beato Angelico

Anywhere you go, if you are a Christian, people will tell you that Christ was not born at Christmas. Sometimes they claim that the Roman Catholic Church took over a pagan holiday, usually Saturnalia; however, Saturnalia always ended before December 23rd. Other times they will say that Christ was really born in spring, or that the choice of December 25th was a reaction against the Emperor Aurelian's choice of December 25th for the festival of "The Birth of the Unconquered Sun". Unfortunately for the critics, Aurelian's choice was probably a pagan reaction to the already-existing Christmas celebrations.

However, did you know that the date of Christ's birth is actually mentioned in the Bible? The problem is for these other folks, that it is not explicitly said in so many words, and so it takes some calculation.

Albrecht Durer - The Penance of St John Chrysostom
This legend might have also come about because Pope Gregory the first, in 601 A.D., directed Augustine to "adopt and adapt native customs." Nevertheless, Christian writers, as early as the third century, had already fixed the date of Christ's birth to the end of December, and likely December 25th. Some of this was symbolical reasoning, but some of it was based simply on counting on one's fingers. The most important summary comes from St. John Chrysostom, patriarch of Constantinople, and the essence of this is laid out below.

Counting backwards

From Christmas, we count backwards nine months to the annunciation. This is when the Archangel Gabriel appeared to the Virgin Mary and offered her the opportunity to bear Christ in her womb. This is narrated in Luke, Chapter 1, verses 26-38. We also note that Elizabeth is "in her sixth month" which is very important to this calculation. So we take date of Christ's birth, - 9 months, equals the date of the annunciation.

Step 2 - still further back

Elizabeth is in her sixth month at the date of the Annunciation. In Luke 1, Zechariah was performing priestly duty in the Temple when an angel told his wife Elizabeth she would bear John the Baptist. Each of the 24 classes of Jewish priests served one week in the Temple, and Zechariah was in the eighth class. Rabbinical tradition fixed the class on duty when the Temple was destroyed in the year 70 and, calculating backward from that, Zechariah's class would have been serving Oct. 2-9 in 5 B.C.

Now, let's count on our fingers . . .

So from the first week in October, we add 24 weeks (4 weeks per month times six months), and we come to a date between March 20th and March 27th. Add nine months to that, and we have a date for Christ's birth between December 20th and December 27th. And there is your answer to the people who say that Christ could not have been born at Christmas!

But What about the Sheep in December?

Two things about the shepherds and their sheep are important. The first is to remember that sheep have wool coats, and that the month of December in Israel has good amounts of precipitation, and high temperatures for the month range in the 60s and 70s. Indeed, in Genesis, we find Jacob reminding Laban that he kept his sheep through "frost by night," thereby implying that at least some shepherds stayed with flocks outside in cold months.

The second thing to remember about the shepherds and their sheep is that some shepherds did not roam to graze sheep, because those sheep were kept nearby the Temple for sacrifices, and therefore stayed in approximately the same place all year. These were the Migdal Eder, and they were viewed as unclean; therefore, they might have been the most appropriate for the announcement of Christ's birth. 

Have a Merry Christmas!

The Temple- Its Ministry and Services
Amazon Price: Buy Now
(price as of Feb 11, 2016)
The classic book in understanding references to the Temple, ritual, and sacrifice in both the Old and New Testaments. Edersheim's critical exegesis may be dry to some readers, but this scholarly work illuminates many Biblical passages with new shades of meaning.


Dec 9, 2009 11:32pm
Interesting. I do have a question, though. Where did you find this information:

"Each of the 24 classes of Jewish priests served one week in the Temple, and Zechariah was in the eighth class. Rabbinical tradition fixed the class on duty when the Temple was destroyed in the year 70 and, calculating backward from that, Zechariah's class would have been serving Oct. 2-9 in 5 B.C."

Having been around for this type of conversation in the past, I find it important to have all of my ducks in a row, because doubters will trip you up.

Other than that, very good! I enjoyed this, and I plan to share this with others.
Dec 10, 2009 10:23am
"Each 'course' of priests and of Levites (as has already been stated) came on duty for a week, from one Sabbath to another." This is from Edelsheim's "The Temple: Its Ministry and Services." Zechariah served in the division of Abijah at the Temple. Scripture records Abijah’s division in 1 Chronicles 24:10 as the eighth out of 24 divisions. The reference is from Chrysostom's sermon given at Antioch, on the feast of St. Philogonius.

And there's more evidence. According to Hippolytus of Rome, in the "Commentary on Daniel" written in 225 A.D., Christ's birth occurs "eight days before the Kalends of January" (December 25th). That well predates the reign of Aurelian (September 9, 214 or 215 – September or October 275) who would have been ten years old at the time. In fact, Aurelian did not enter his rule until 270 A.D., and instituted the "Unconquered Sun" festival in 274 A.D., almost fifty years after Hippolytus.

David Morrison offers this: "The angel Gabriel appeared to Mary "in the sixth month" of the Jewish year...that is, in Adar (our February/March). Count nine months for the pregnancy and you come to Kislev (our November/December). According to some Church Fathers, Jesus was born during Channukah. Therefore, Jesus Christ was born of the Holy Virgin Mary in Bethlehem of Judaea in the Jewish month of Kislev (December) during the Festival of Lights. And I say likely on what is December 25th."

And there's another reference: Zechariah entered the Temple on Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement, where he received the announcement of the conception of John the Forerunner. Yom Kippur falls in late September. Add the fifteen months to that (6 months to the Annunciation, plus 9 more months) and you get late December.

I hope this helps you with the doubters!
Dec 10, 2009 10:35am
The so-called evidence for the choice of December 25th as a co-opt of the pagan festivals actually begins with the Reformation. Jablonski asserts it because the Reformation is a reaction to the Roman Catholic Church, and he is trying to discredit it. Sir Isaac Newton also believed this, but as smart as he was, Newton believed in a lot of things that have been discredited. In fact, most of the "evidence" of the seventeenth- and eighteenth-century writers on the subject who support this theory has been discredited, starting the early twentieth century, by French liturgical scholars.
Dec 10, 2009 10:36am
starting IN the early twentieth century . . . sorry, still on my first cup of coffee.
Aug 24, 2010 6:43pm
Very fascinating. Thanks for the lesson and references.
Dec 11, 2010 6:46pm
I agree that this is fascinating. Thanks for sharing and all the research!
Dec 11, 2010 8:47pm
Very interesting article. Thank you for your research and for sharing.
Add a new comment - No HTML
You must be logged in and verified to post a comment. Please log in or sign up to comment.

Explore InfoBarrel

Auto Business & Money Entertainment Environment Health History Home & Garden InfoBarrel University Lifestyle Sports Technology Travel & Places
© Copyright 2008 - 2016 by Hinzie Media Inc. Terms of Service Privacy Policy XML Sitemap

Follow IB Lifestyle