Forgot your password?

Is College Worth It? Maybe, But it Certainly Ain't What it Used to Be!

By Edited Oct 18, 2016 4 10

Career Advice

As college costs continue to soar and with unemployment still at uncomfortably high levels, more and more people are asking an important question. "Is college worth it?" The answer to that question is not as simple as it would appear on the face of it. Tuition increases every year and that will never is not likely to change. Even parents who started saving before their child was born have a high chance of footing the bill by taking out or co-signing on loans to pay for college expenses. Even so, research consistently shows that people with four-year degrees earn significantly more in their life times than high school graduates. How much more? Factoring in the cost of the education itself, the average four-year degree holder stands to earn about $550,000 more than someone who stopped at high school.[1] Is college worth it? The answer seems amazingly clear, right? Not so fast. That half million dollars in additional earnings is just an average and varies greatly. Let’s consider a few things:

[RELATED: Cut College Costs: 7 Tips that Colleges Hope You Won't Use]

Consideration #1: Examine College Costs Closely:

Whether you have just started looking at schools, are currently enrolled, or have graduated, you know that college costs can vary significantly from institution to institution. Community colleges tend to be the most economical, followed by state, then private schools. Your out-of-pocket costs for each type of school varies greatly and can determine college costs and future college debt. Looking squarely at the cold hard cash cost of attendance, this is how the different schools measured up in the 2012-2013 year:

  • 4-Year State Colleges: Students who attended their state school paid an average of $2900 a year after factoring in grants (i.e. federal and/or state grants, external grants and scholarships, and institutional grants and scholarships), loans and tax credits.
  • 4-Year Private Colleges: Four year private schools were the most expensive on average. Students paid an average of $13,000 a year after grants, loans and tax credits.
  • 2-Year Colleges (Community Colleges): Two year schools were the least expensive with students effectively paying nothing after grants and tax credits.[2]

It’s important to note that these expenses do not include room and board, so if you are planning to live on campus, tack on another $10,000. It is also important to note that college costs start to increase as family income increases because family income dictates eligibility for some types of financial aid.

Pink Piggy Bank On Top Of A Pile Of One Dollar Bills

If college expenses can be paid without taking out loans, then students have effectively increased their earning potential after they graduate because they don’t have to worry about paying back debt. If students do have to take out loans, it would be far better to incur lower college debt by selecting a less expensive school than one with higher tuition. So, is college worth it if you choose a lower cost one to attend? A logical conclusion might be yes! But not so fast! It still depends.

[RELATED: Two Ways to Graduate Early and Save and Save Thousands on College Costs]

Debt-Free U: How I Paid for an Outstanding College Education Without Loans, Scholarships, or Mooching off My Parents
Amazon Price: $16.00 $1.99 Buy Now
(price as of Oct 18, 2016)
A first-hand account of how to save thousands on college.

Consideration #2: Does it Matter What You Major In?

Do college majors really make a difference? Yes, in many instances they do. Many school administrators gloss over this fact, telling students instead, “Do what you enjoy and the money will follow.” I am actually a big proponent of this idea because our careers take up a large portion of our lives and it’s better for our souls if we can work at something we enjoy. If work is more like play, you won’t regret it. However, with the reality of more than half of recent college graduates being unemployed or underemployed at jobs that I am sure they never envisioned doing with a degree[3], it is worth examining the relationship between college majors and college costs.

So what college majors are worth it? Majors that lead to careers needing a specific skill such as business, accounting, computers and engineering can have a much bigger financial payoff than majors such as liberal arts or history. Sadly, students who major in education earned only $80,000 more over their work lifetime than high school graduates.[1] Personally, given the importance of great teachers in this country this is a travesty. Even worse, the additional earnings could be wiped out if students attend an expensive school and rack up enormous college debt. That’s not so hard to do, especially if you are incurring other college expenses such as room and board.

[RELATED: Cut College Costs While in High School: Two Programs that Really Work]

Okay, so is college worth it if you attend a lower cost school and select a college major that will earn more money? Well … maybe. It depends.

Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 (7-Inch, Wi-Fi) 2012 Model
Amazon Price: $179.99 $165.00 Buy Now
(price as of Oct 18, 2016)
Designed to fit in one hand, typing messages or notes is simple and easy with the Galaxy Tab's virtual QWERTY keyboard

Consideration #3: Does it Matter Where You Go to College?

There are differing opinions on the answer to this question. An elite college certainly provides bragging rights and if attending a more prestigious school means making significantly more money over your lifetime, even if that means taking on more college debt, it’s probably worth it, right? Once again, it depends. Research shows that unless you go to a top-tier school (think Harvard and Yale), what’s more important to future earning is the college major selected.[4] In other words, when trying to decide between the two, it’s important to look at your choice of major. If you are interested in a college major that is on the lower end of the pay scale once you graduate, it may be better to attend a less expensive school. If you’re pursuing a major that leads to a career on the higher end of the pay scale, a highly ranked school, especially one that specializes in that field of study may be worth it. Okay, so … does it matter where you go to college? Well before you decide, consider one more thing.


Consideration # 4: Not Everything is about Money. What about the College Experience?

A product of a university education, as well as having worked with many, many students over the years, I do personally believe that the college experience is invaluable. But it is also important to ask what it is worth. While studies show that a healthy 74% of students believe that higher education provides an opportunity for intellectual growth and 69% believe that it helps them to mature, an underwhelming 55% believe that it actually prepares them for a job. Worse, when compared with high school graduates, college graduates don’t find their jobs much more interesting (53% of college grads vs. 51% of high school grads). Even so, a very high percentage of graduates (86%) believe that it was a good investment.[5] During my most cynical moments I sometimes wonder if the belief is simply the result of brainwashing that happens when spending a gazillion dollars on that education and a good portion of your life paying off college debt. You almost HAVE to say that it was worth it or how much self-loathing would there be? 

iOttie Easy One Touch Windshield Dashboard Car Mount Holder for iPhone 7/6s/6, Galaxy S7/S6- Retail Packaging- Black
Amazon Price: $24.99 $16.95 Buy Now
(price as of Oct 18, 2016)
Easy one-touch mounting system locks and releases the device with just a push of a finger.

In all seriousness All kidding aside, the college experience is something to factor in. Amenities vary significantly. Smaller versus large class sizes. Residence halls. Special classes. Extracurricular activities. Career development opportunities. Connections with alumni who can be helpful in your career. Life-long friendships. They are all important aspects of the college experience. However, all of this will mean nothing to your future if you do not fully take advantage of it. Schools with fewer amenities can offer a marvelous college experience. It really is what you make of it.

So, what’s the verdict? Is college worth it? Ultimately each person needs to decide, but hopefully these considerations are helpful when weighing your options.



May 22, 2013 3:22pm
Another good book to read on this topic: "Is College Worth It?" by William Bennett. He served as Reagan's Secretary of Education.

This seems to be becoming a bigger and bigger issue nowadays. Tuition costs and student debt continue to rise, yet the security of getting a job continues to decline.
May 22, 2013 5:25pm
Alex-Gopson: Thanks for reading and commenting. Also, thanks for the book recommendation. I am going to check it out.
May 22, 2013 3:58pm
Great article, I enjoyed it. I'm going to read it once more. Thanks!
May 22, 2013 5:26pm
dieselfit: Thank you so much for reading and commenting. I'm glad you enjoyed it!
May 22, 2013 7:15pm
Kim, you did a great job of explaining the pros and cons of a college degree. This is an ongoing debate in America and will continue to be as long as college costs increase. Unfortunately, many people do not consider blue-collar occupations such as welding, construction, and auto mechanics. I think that community colleges are an outstanding alternative to the traditional 4-year university. They are cheaper and provide good job training. Thanks for the article, Kim.
May 23, 2013 6:54pm
curisoity-And the debate is raging, indeed. Not too long ago (relatively speaking) Iowa had the highest SAT score. It turned out that the probably reason was because only 3% of the students intended to go to college. There are plenty of well paying professions that don't need a degree. AND research is starting to suggest that community college grads are making more money that their 4-year school counterparts (depending on the major). Thanks for the read and comment. I appreciate it!
May 23, 2013 7:33am
A thought provoking article for all those young people who will be making the big decision. This article benefits both the student and their parents, and it will make good dinnertime discussion.
Another amazing read! Thumbs Up!
May 23, 2013 6:50pm
Thanks for the read, comment and support southergirl. It means a lot! :)
May 23, 2013 11:05pm
Interesting article that poses important questions. During the last decades education has become a profitable industry (not only in U.S.) and a costly investment for students. The recent economic crisis and the rise of unemployment seem to have altered the way people/students see higher education.
May 25, 2013 6:37pm
Elias, thanks for reading and commenting. What's interesting to me is that in come ways colleges need to operate like businesses in terms of nimbleness, but by and large they do not. Fields of study that are no longer profitable need to be re-envisioned to that they are relevant, but many times they are not. The argument is that college is about growth and learning and being well-rounded. Agreed. But are we not doing a students a disservice by having them spend so much money on something that may not see a return? I think Forbes just published and article which stated that something like 1/3 of millennials wish they hadn't gone to college. It's a conversation worth having. Thanks again!
Add a new comment - No HTML
You must be logged in and verified to post a comment. Please log in or sign up to comment.


  1. "Is College Worth It?." http://www.pewsocialtrends.org. 15/05/2011. 14/04/2013 <Web >
  2. College Board Advocacy and Policy Center "Trends in College Pricing 2012." http://trends.collegeboard.org. 14/04/2013 <Web >
  3. Jordan Weissmann "53% of Recent College Grads Are Jobless or Underemployed—How?." http://www.theatlantic.com/. 23/04/2012. 14/04/2013 <Web >
  4. "Does It Matter Where You Go to School?." http://www.payscale.com. 5/09/2012. 15/04/2013 <Web >
  5. "Is College Worth It?." http://www.time.com/. 15/04/2013 <Web >

Explore InfoBarrel

Auto Business & Money Entertainment Environment Health History Home & Garden InfoBarrel University Lifestyle Sports Technology Travel & Places
© Copyright 2008 - 2016 by Hinzie Media Inc. Terms of Service Privacy Policy XML Sitemap

Follow IB Lifestyle