Login
Password

Forgot your password?

Psychics, Fortune Tellers, and Astrologers: Therapists or Frauds?

By Edited Dec 28, 2015 1 1

According to the scientific community parapsychology is something that elicits skepticism or even down right disbelief.  This is due mostly to there being no reliable tests that can establish psychic abilities.  Though the scientific community often “lumps in” fortune tellers, psychics and astrologers with parapsychologists; true parapsychologists do not consider fortune tellers or astrologers to be parapsychologists.[3]  According to the Parapsychology Association, founded in 1957, included in the study of parapsychology are the following:[3]

  • Telepathy:  the transfer of information without the use of the five senses
  • Precognition: information about the future
  • Clairvoyance: information about places or events at remote locations
  • Psychokinesis: mind influence of time, matter, space, or energy
  • Reincarnation: rebirth of the soul or other aspects of non-physical consciousness
  • Hauntings: ghosts
  • Near-death and Out-of-Body experience
  • Poltergeists: large scale psychokinesis that were thought to be spirits but are now thought to be living persons

Skeptics of Psychics, Fortune Tellers and Astrologers vs. Parapsychologists

Skeptics of psychics, fortune tellers and/or astrologers often include these people in the parapsychology field.  Skeptics theorize the popularity of these “professions” is due to people’s desire to believe in paranormal phenomenon and discounting any evidence it doesn’t exist.

Skeptics site the fact there are no experiments conducted in parapsychology that can be easily repeated; experiments are inadequately controlled; many magic tricks can simulate supposed psychic phenomenon; and thus, most fortune tellers and psychics are frauds.[1]   They claim most results of any studies conducted are reported selectively—positive reports are the only ones made public.  Simply because something is popular doesn’t mean it is valid or reliable.

Psychics; photo by Jackie, source: flickr

Skeptics describe two aspects of events with fortune tellers, astrologers or psychics:[1]

  • The Barnum effect- people interpret general statements as applying specifically and accurately to their own unique circumstance.
  • Cold reading- a set of techniques, such as reading body language, used by psychic readers that create the impression that they have psychic abilities.

Paul Zenon on BBC news

Talking about his training to be a psychic

Parapsychologists take their work very seriously.  They define a parapsychologist as a scientist or scholar who is seriously interested in the paranormal; which they describe as unusual events associated with the human experience.[3]  True parapsychologists consider fortune tellers, psychic readers and astrologers as entertainers, not scientists.[3]   Parapsychology is based on two types of energy: energy of matter and energy behind matter.  Religion calls energy behind matter spiritual energy and the scientific community calls it the energy of the quantum vacuum.

Are Psychics, Astrologers, and Fortune Tellers Therapists?

In 1982, David Lester, Ph,D. conducted a personal study to examine the relationship between astrologers and psychics and traditional therapy methods.  His theory was these people had a similar role to therapists; and people seek the services of these people in part due to the stigma of mental illness when seeing a therapist.[1]  Notably, in the relationship there is one who understands and knows; and one who is seeking knowledge and understanding.

Lester hypothesized the techniques used by astrologers, fortune tellers and psychics were parallel to many systems of psychotherapy; in particular to the relationship between therapist and client.[1]   Therapy is based on several assumptions:

  • The relationship between the therapist and client is such that the client has confidence in the power of the therapist. The relationship is limited and controlled.
  • Therapy is based on a theory there is something which explains the disturbance of the client.
  • Therapy involves some type of procedure involving some effort on the client’s part.
  • Frequency, duration and timing of visits are determined.

Many people seek the guidance of astrologers or psychics instead of psychotherapists; especially in regards to issues such as changing jobs.  In the Hindu religion, parties often consult an astrologer to determine the compatibility of potential spouses.   Lester met with an astrologer, a fortune teller who read the tarot cards, and a palm reader.   He observed the interactions and methods used by each.

Astrology;  Source: Wikimedia Commons

Lester found similarities in the methods used by these three people and traditional psychotherapists.  Each one, to varying degrees attempted to connect with him to form a “professional-client” relationship.  He saw similarities between the methods used by these people to methods used by therapists such as Carl Roger’s client-centered therapy or Carl Jung’s theory of introvert-extrovert.  Does that make these people therapists?

The majority of people turn to friends or family as the first source of advice.  Are they then to be considered therapists?  Using a very loose definition, then a case could be made that indeed friends, family, or anyone who offers advice is a therapist.  What is more important, however, is the issue of what type of help is needed.

People who have a serious mental disorder need the care of a professional who has training in the field.  While astrologers, fortune tellers or psychics have their niche, they are not trained in the field of mental disorders and therefore, cannot be called psychotherapists.  Until a body of reliable and valid scientific studies is conducted with measurable results, they will not be taken seriously by the scientific community.  Are they frauds?  That also will continue to be debated.

 

The copyright of the article Psychics, Fortune Tellers, and Astrologers:  Therapists or Frauds? is owned by Cheryl Weldon and permission to republish in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.

Astrology for Yourself: How to Understand And Interpret Your Own Birth Chart
Amazon Price: $19.95 $11.49 Buy Now
(price as of Dec 28, 2015)
Advertisement
Advertisement

Comments

Aug 3, 2010 12:51pm
divaonline
Interesting article!
Add a new comment - No HTML
You must be logged in and verified to post a comment. Please log in or sign up to comment.

Bibliography

  1. David Lester Ph.D. "Astrologers and psychics as therapists." American Journal of Psychology . XXXVI (1982): 56-66.
  2. "Astrology." World-Mysteries.com . 10/07/2010 <Web >
  3. "Parapsychology ." Parapsychology Association. 10/07/2010 <Web >

Explore InfoBarrel

Auto Business & Money Entertainment Environment Health History Home & Garden InfoBarrel University Lifestyle Sports Technology Travel & Places
© Copyright 2008 - 2016 by Hinzie Media Inc. Terms of Service Privacy Policy XML Sitemap

Follow IB Health