Login
Password

Forgot your password?

Should You Get An Acoustic Or Electric Guitar?

By Edited Nov 13, 2013 0 2

Acoustic and Electric Guitar Circle
The first question most prospective guitar students ask me is whether they should start on acoustic or electric guitar.  This is a quick rundown of the pros and cons of each.  You should be able to make a decision from there.

Neither guitar is better or worse than the other.  They're just different versions of the same instrument.  Both are tuned the same way and have six strings. 

Here are some of the main ideas to think about in making your decision...

1. What kind of music are you interested in playing?  Death metal, punk, and rock?  Go for the electric.  Classical, delta blues, or country?  An acoustic is probably a better choice.

2. Do you want to start with the easiest or get the hard work out of the way at the beginning?  Acoustic guitars are a little harder to play due to the factors I'll explain below.  If you'd rather put the work in at the beginning, starting on acoustic and moving to electric later is very easy.  Moving from electric to acoustic takes a little additional work.

Acoustic Guitar
Pros:
- Builds better hand strength
- Encourages better tone because you're not being helped by technology
Cons:
- Thicker strings can be harder on your hands and fingers until you build up strength and calluses
- While rather quiet, it can't be played silently (a concern for apartment dwellers)

Electric Guitar
Pros:
- Lighter strings are easier on your hands and fingers at first
- Can be played silently if your amplifier has a headphone jack
- Not as much hand strength needed
Cons:
- Moving to acoustic afterwards can be harder as you'll need to increase hand strength
- Reliance on distortion and effects can make for sloppy technique
- Need to learn more muting techniques to deal with amplified sound

Personally, I started on acoustic guitar.  A really terrible, difficult to play one too.  I moved to electric later on and still play both regularly.  As I mentioned, the transition from acoustic to electric is easy.  The transition from electric to acoustic usually means having to tone up your hand muscles a bit before feeling comfortable.  You'll also need to get used to the larger body of an acoustic guitar.

If you do start on electric guitar, make sure to practice a lot without distortion and effects that mask sloppy playing.  Playing clean will help you catch stuff you need to fix.  Go ahead and use those effects when it's time to rock though.

The decision to start with acoustic or electric guitar depends on your goals as a player and the type of student you are.  My suggestion is starting with acoustic guitar, but your own goals should be the deciding factor.
Advertisement

Comments

Jan 6, 2012 12:35am
aguy
I started with electric guitar when I was 8. I didn't get an acoustic guitar till I graduated from college. So - I am sort of the opposite of your experience. I just liked electric guitar better, so that is why I started with it. It was the obvious choice for me considering my life goal to be a rock star.
Mar 22, 2012 1:58pm
PhilJohnson
Yep, it can really go either way. And sometimes there's just not a choice. I only had an acoustic to start with in my case.
Add a new comment - No HTML
You must be logged in and verified to post a comment. Please log in or sign up to comment.

Explore InfoBarrel

Auto Business & Money Entertainment Environment Health History Home & Garden InfoBarrel University Lifestyle Sports Technology Travel & Places
© Copyright 2008 - 2016 by Hinzie Media Inc. Terms of Service Privacy Policy XML Sitemap

Follow IB Entertainment