"I Wanted To See How She Would Act!"
Juvenile killers (particularly children who murder other children) are a separate breed from the run-of-the-mill killer. Their motives are often informed by immaturity (a famous New Zealand case, the Parker-Hulme murder case in the mid 20th Century, saw two lesbian narcissistic female “chums” murder the mother of one of the duo).Credit: Boston Globe
Many times blame may be laid at the doorstep of bad parenting or a poor home environment (poverty, lack of education, etc.). Motive isn’t important – what is important is that a murderer (versus someone who kills accidentally) makes a conscious decision, even if that decision is reached in a nanosecond’s worth of brain activity, to commit the act.
Rarely in the history of murder has it been shown that a child murderer was actually mentally incompetent when committing a murder. The cunning Jesse Pomeroy, America’s first notorious child murderer, was no exception to that; he was never found incompetent, and he was the youngest person convicted of first-degree murder in the history of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.
Jesse’s community standing was probably better than most (both parents employed, a solid home). He had the misfortune, however, of being physically different from his peers. He was large for his age, and ungainly. He had an occluded right eye (noted by historians and the press of the time as a “milky” eye). He was reported to have a harelip, but this doesn’t seem to be borne out by photographs and contemporary illustrations. His mouth is unusually compressed, and the corners do not seem completely developed; this is what may look like a harelip. His intelligence was reportedly on the lower end of the spectrum. If Jesse Pomeroy was not so bright he was cunning. He was also a malignant, sadistic sociopath.
The Pomeroy family made a move to South Boston in 1872. Jesse’s attacks on local boys increased during this time. He specifically targeted boys younger and weaker than he, ranging from the ages of seven to eleven years old. According to a later news report (from the New York Times, April 24, 1874), Pomeroy had “stripped, gagged, tied to a telegraph pole, whipped and cut with a knife in the head” one of his young victims.
Pomeroy's assaults escalated and, because of his unique characteristics (mostly the “milky” eye), was finally positively identified and arrested. His case went before a local juvenile court judge. Pomeroy was found guilty of the torture crimes. He was sentenced to the Lyman School for Boys at Westborough, Massachusetts, until he turned 18. The Boston Globe reported on the proceedings (in part): “It is generally concluded that the boy is mentally deficient.” [This statement would later prove false.] He did not serve all of his time, however. He was paroled when he was 14 (in 1874). He returned to his mother’s dressmaker shop where he helped out. Charles, his brother, sold newspapers.
On April 23, 1874, Pomeroy tortured and brutally murdered a small boy in a marsh in Dorchester Bay. The little boy had last been seen leaving his own home to buy candy. The next day (April 24, 1874) the mutilated body of four-year-old Horace Millen was discovered. He had multiple stab wounds and slashes, and a stab wound (tellingly) to his right eye. Millen’s genitals had also been stabbed.
Millen’s body was made available and, later that day, Pomeroy was taken to the coroner's office to see it. He then confessed (without counsel being present), adding the detail that he had wiped blood from his knife by dipping it in the mud. When asked why he had killed Millen, he replied “I couldn’t help it.”
In July of the same year (four months after her disappearance) Pomeroy confessed to killing Katie Curran. He had been working alone in his mother’s shop when Curran came in. He had coaxed her into the basement of his mother's dress shop, cut her throat, and then buried her under an ash heap. The girl’s body had been haphazardly and carelessly covered up. Pomeroy, when confronted for this killing, and asked for a reason, said, “I wanted to see how she would act.”
On December 10, 1874, after a jury’s quick deliberation, Pomeroy was found guilty of the two torture murders. They recommended mercy in sentencing, however, because of Pomeroy’s youth. His lawyer filed two exceptions; these were overruled in February 1875, and Pomeroy was sentenced to death by hanging.
Governor William Gaston was supposed to then sign Pomeroy’s death warrant and produce an execution date. He flatly refused to do either – he did not want to send the boy to his death. Pomeroy’s lawyer latched onto this reticence and lobbied before the Governor’s Council for a commutation of Pomeroy’s death sentence. Over the next 18 months, the Council debated the issue on three separate occasions. In three votes on the commutation issue for Pomeroy the first two votes upheld his execution, but Governor Gaston still refused to sign a death warrant for the boy. Finally, in August 1876, they took a third vote, anonymously. Pomeroy's sentence was commuted to life in prison, with the provision it be served in solitary confinement. On the evening of September 7, 1876, Pomeroy went to the State Prison at Charlestown.
He then began a life of solitary confinement. He was 16 years and 9 months old upon entering the prison system.
Pomeroy was not a model prisoner. He expressed no remorse for the murders of the two children, and he maintained he was wrongfully incarcerated his entire life. Pomeroy spent most of his time hatching escape plans. He made tools (such as chisels, knives, and picks) from metal pried off various objects or from finding things in the exercise yard (on rare occasions when he was let out). His prison records show disciplinary action for escape attempts every year of his imprisonment, sometimes several times a year. His attempts ranged from the rudimentary (scraping holes in his wall or otherwise trying to dig out) to the more adventurous. Once, Pomeroy managed to break a gas line in his cell. He intended to ignite the gas, blowing a hole in his cell wall through which he could escape. The gas filled his cell; upon ignition it blew Pomeroy, senseless and burned, into the wall instead. A guard discovered him knocked out in his cell.
When not physically trying to escape, Pomeroy spent time using the legal system to effect his release. He became fairly well-versed in the law. He spent hours reading law books and creating requests for documents from the courts. An added bonus (for the self-centered Pomeroy) was that his repeated escape attempts kept him in the limelight. He loved media attention every time he was caught trying to escape. He also bragged about each escapade as he described to reporters how he did it.
Pomeroy spent 41 years in solitary confinement, the second-longest term of any American prisoner. In 1917 (after his only human contacts were his keepers and the occasional newsman), Pomeroy was transferred to the general prison population. He resisted this, claiming he didn’t want a mere transfer but a full pardon instead. This was just a ploy; he wanted to stay in solitary. After three months of wrangling he was moved to general population.
This actually represented a severe change in lifestyle for him. He was no longer able to control the temperature in his environment, nor could he keep up his personal library. Furthermore, he had to work, but he was such a nuisance about it (purposefully annoying the guards, breaking work-detail rules, etc.) that guards absolved him of any further labor. Pomeroy preferred this; the guards were likewise spared the negative publicity of having to constantly discipline the “poor man” who’d been in solitary for so long. Pomeroy eventually threw in the towel and adapted to the new life. He even appeared in a minstrel show at the prison.
In 1929 (elderly and in bad health) he was transferred out of Charlestown State Prison to Bridgewater Hospital for the Criminally Insane (the same facility that would later house Albert DeSalvo, the man – probably erroneously – convicted of being the notorious Boston Strangler).
Pomeroy died of heart disease in Bridgewater on September 29, 1932. He was 72 years old. He had spent 59 years in prison, 41 of these years in solitary. He never repented, he never expressed remorse, and he lived his life in prison as a true narcissist. He was the center of attention for many years and that’s how he liked it.
“(1) Delusional insanity; (2) Insanity from masturbation; (3) Epileptiform insanity; (4) Moral insanity; and (5) Moral imbecility”
He was determined not delusional, and he was cunning enough (displaying normal intelligence) to attempt concealment of Curran’s body, a sure sign of someone who is not mentally incompetent. He knew his crimes were wrong and he tried to hide them. The alienists concluded, after examining Pomeroy:
“The idea that Pomeroy may be suffering from delusional insanity has now been quite generally abandoned. No delusions have been found, and a person of his limited intelligence could not have concealed them had they existed.”
Another alienist observed Pomeroy was physically and intellectually average, and he was able to decide the difference between right and wrong when presented hypothetical scenarios to evaluate. However, another alienist wrote, “He evinces no pity for the boys tortured or for the victims of his homicide, and no remorse or sorrow for his acts.”
Although the alienists’ terminology differs from today’s jargon, in summary they did not find Pomeroy mentally ill or unbalanced in his mental health. They found instead what today is called a sadist and a malignant narcissist whose whole world revolved around him without regard for others.
Insane? No. “Evil”? Perhaps. Simply an all-around psychopath? Absolutely. Jesse Pomeroy’s 59 years in prison were not enough to erase his memory from the criminal landscape, though – he remains the youngest person sentenced to death in Massachusetts history, and his extended incarceration in solitary is likewise a record of endurance.
Amazon Price: $16.95 $10.45 Buy Now
(price as of Mar 21, 2016)
ficitional account based on the real Parker-Hulme murder case
starring Melanie Lynskey & Kate Winslet
Amazon Price: $21.13 Buy Now
(price as of Mar 21, 2016)